Wifi AP mode on the Wandboard

Getting to ap mode has been a struggle due to closed source firmware, vendor-modified driver… I am going to reiterate the whole story here, so if you just want the solution simply skip to the end of this post.

The wandboard has a bcm4329 which is a design by Broadcom and therefore requires a binary firmware and a compatible driver.
A few months ago, someone posted a thread asking for ap mode on the wandboard because the chip apparently supporty it but the backported brcfmac with the firmware delivered by linux-firmware or the one in wandboard-firmware doesn’t.

Mr. Tapani (he’s with the wandboard-project) then asked their manufacturer for a better firmware and/or a better driver and finally received a response (though hindered by a forwarding chain… business reasons of course).
The packaged they received was later posted in the forums and it included a firmware and a the “bcmdhd” driver which should support the ap mode.

After some trouble compiling the kernel (which needed a kernel patch) I got it to compile and inserted the module. Using hostapd, I even got it to run as an ap (it was visible on my android phone) and was able to connect and ping afterwards. It all worked on open mode, but after I added encryption it stopped working. With enabled WPA/WPA2, the ap was still visible, but you could not connect to it.

Tapani replied to the manufacturer and received new instructions (README as a PNG File…) involving a mysterious ‘wl’ utility. I tried the instructions from the PNG and tried to improvise using the manual I found here, but I did not have any success with it (ap wasn’t even visible).

Afer all that, I’ve realized that the brcmfmac driver (which is completely open source but relies on the binary firmware) does actually include ap support! The version used in the wandboards 3.0.35 kernel (which is still the stable release for i.MX6 devices :/) is backported by Tapani from 3.5rc7 and is too old to support ap mode though :/
I tried using the (early) 3.10.17 kernel which includes a new brcmfmac driver and it actually worked! Even with WPA2 I was able to connect, authenticate and ping on the newly established connection! Sadly though, this driver was not available on 3.0.35.

But there is help for the older kernel after all: The backports-project allow you to compile and run drivers from the most recent linux (3.13 in this case) to run on kernels as old as 2.6.xx (in the case of brcmfmac it’s 2.6.29). This allowed me to compile the driver from 3.10.17 and run it on 3.0.35! And here we go again, ap mode worked!

The problem with this method was, that I had not tried to have any actual traffic on the wandboard (more than just a simple ping, iperf for example). Heavy traffic resulted in loads of

[ 5630.178929] brcmfmac: brcmf_sdio_buffrw: sg request length 964 is not 512 aligned

on serial and huge connection problems on client side.
But as I have come this far, I just could not resign and tried the newer version from 3.13 (again, using the backports-project). Again, ap mode worked with WPA2 and this time the error message was gone! I was actually able to sustain like 10mbit over the wandboards ap!

I wrote down my build-instructions using a Archlinux PKGBUILD file which you can find here. It downloads the 3.13-stable kernel source, the 3.13-compatible version of backports and compiles the modules ‘compat/compat.ko’,’net/wireless/cfg80211.ko’, ‘drivers/net/wireless/brcm80211/brcmutil/brcmutil.ko’ and ‘drivers/net/wireless/brcm80211/brcmfmac/brcmfmac.ko’ and adds them to the updates/ folder of your kernel. It also extracts the firmware from the archive Tapani posted and puts it in the respective /usr/lib/firmware/brcm location for the brcmfmac driver.

Afer running a depmod and then modprobe’ing the brcmfmac module, your wandboard will now support ap mode (via hostapd).

If you need more build instructions, just drop me a note.

Hello, could you send me the package of
Wifi AP mode on the Wandboard

I am new to Linux, cannot build on Wandboard because of missing coccinelle package, on vmware makepkg gives error: not for X86_64.

Thank u very much!

Matthias
fi.ma@web.de

Hi Hanny,

I am having the same problem as Matthias. I am not great with linux yet either. I tried building the coccinelle package with ‘armv7h’ added like you mentioned, but still having issues. It appears coccinelle installed correctly but it is tough to tell because there are some many warnings and such. I do get the the “Finished making: coccinelle 1.0.0rc19-1,” so I figured that was a good sign.

However, when I go to build your package, I still get that a missing package “coccinelle” error. Any ideas?

Thanks,

DOT850

Did you actually install the package after you built it?
I changed the arch array to armv7h, build and installed the package it worked…

Yes, I hadn’t installed the package yet, that was my problem!

I told you I was new to the linux world. Thanks for the help!

David

Hanny, I’m glad you like the new kernel (3.10.17) that I’ve been working on! In your case, using the 3.10.17 kernel, were you able to get AP mode working without the special firmware Tapani recieved? I’m trying to get AP mode working on it with the default firmware downloaded from the linux-firmware repository, but haven’t had much luck yet.

So, BCM4329 is now supported by hostapd? How was the performance? Does it support dual-band?

I am new to WiFi, tried installing wifi on wandboard quad using yocto(dizzy) core-image-minimal but it is not successful. I tried with the following link
https://eewiki.net/display/linuxonarm/Wandboard#Wandboard-WiFi

following is the dmesg log
8.349145] brcmfmac: brcmf_cfg80211_reg_notifier: not a ISO3166 code (0x30 0x30)
[ 8.766726] Bluetooth: BNEP (Ethernet Emulation) ver 1.3
[ 8.766738] Bluetooth: BNEP filters: protocol multicast
[ 8.766766] Bluetooth: BNEP socket layer initialized
[ 10.598296] brcmfmac: brcmf_p2p_create_p2pdev: timeout occurred
[ 10.604267] brcmfmac: brcmf_cfg80211_add_iface: add iface p2p-dev-wlan0 type 10 failed: err=-5
[ 10.635698] IPv6: ADDRCONF(NETDEV_UP): wlan0: link is not ready
[ 74.630260] random: crng init done

Could you guide me further
Looking for support immediately.

9 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Checkbox GDPR is required

*

I agree

Hardware
Aus dem Archiv: keyComfort – Der besondere Fahrradsattel

An dieser Stelle möchte in unserem Sommer-Format “Aus dem Archiv” ein besonders kreatives und ausgefallenes Projekt vorstellen: keyComfort. Um garnicht erst viel Worte zu verlieren, lasse ich einfach das großartige Video unserer Indiegogo Crowdfunding-Kampagne (Web-Archiv 1,2) sprechen: Trotz seiner ansprechenden Ästhetik und professionellen Machart ging die Kampagne weder dort noch …

Hardware
Aus dem Archiv: CNC-Fräse Lightning Talk GPN10

Eigentlich hatten wir, Benibr, ST und ich damals 2010 schon verschiedene Texte zur GPN10, der Gulaschprogrammiernacht des Entropias in Karlsruhe, veröffentlicht. Auch der Talk von ST und Robert hatte erwähnung gefunden. Die Aufzeichnung zu dem Vortrag über die erste, selbstgebaute CNC-Fräse wurde aber leider noch nicht verlinkt oder hier hochgeladen. …

Hardware
Fix a bend bicycle fork

Bend forks are hard to fix — I thought. But to get it somewhat straight is sometimes not that big of a deal! This is the bend fork. It is also the reason that made the bike go to trash before I saved it: To bend the fork back to …